Or would any other singer have achieved same impact on singing his(MD’s songs as you say) songs. Rafi sahb was not a composer, but can we say that he had no singing of his own. And, final rendition is as important if not more. It is not fair to assume the ‘feeling’ part being restricted to MD and Lyricist alone.Ĭomposing comes first, agree. Singing and Instrumentation are as artistic activities, as are composing and lyric writing.Composing, Orchestration, Lyrics, Singing, Instrument playing, Instruments themselves are all important building blocks of a song and demand emotional involvement on the part of Composer, Lyricist, Singer, Musician.
MD brings a tune, Lyricist gets words, the people who play and sing it also matter. Going by the reasoning in your point, should we say that Music director and Lyricist are only ones adding emotional touch to a piece of art, and all other artists who actually render it are robots operating on instructions ? The only plus point is that human voice gives language to music but then again that language is of the lyricist….”Īs a musician, I have to disagree with it. They have no singing of their own…….they sing their notes like a musician plays his. Panshul Mehta Nandu Belvalkar ji, regarding your above point in which you mention – “Every playback singer is a vocal instrument… like a Sax or Accordion.
0 kommentar(er)
